Especially since, as Ella puts it, theres a kind of feedback loop of gentrifiers complain[ing] about gentrification without acknowledging that they're complicit., When asked what Penn owes to the communities it inhabits, Phil talks for a while before pausing to take a deep breath: It just owes them their space.. In the 2010s, Philadelphia tried to strike an equilibrium between development and stasis, renewal and disruption, gentrification and decay. The social boundaries that were most clear to us were evident in the areas past 48th, as prior to this crossroad the district was conspicuously opulent. Its exhausting work. This house on the corner of Second and Lombard Streets used building materials typically used in adjacent row houses, such as brick and concrete, but applied a modernist design to give the building its distinctive look. In the nineteenth century, West Philadelphia transformed from a countryside of family farms and "gentlemen's" estates to a set of residential communities. The old Gothic auditorium will be turned into a coworking space and a coffee shop. Notice that many of the suburban and industrial areas were ineligible to gentrify because they had too few people or were too wealthy. In particular, the western stretch of this arearebranded as Graduate Hospitalsaw a dramatic influx of young, white, well-off residents, drawn by its proximity to tony Rittenhouse Square and easy accessibility to the University of Pennsylvania. . Gentrification could not occur without the initial separation of Greater Philadelphia's residents by class, race, and country of origin. New York: Oxford University Press, 2013. What these struggles make plain is the violence that is fundamentally intertwined with private property rights and the shadowy public-private partnerships often involved. Like many Philadelphia neighborhoods that experienced a middle-class influx, rising rents and tax assessments made life increasingly difficult for poorer residents. You didn't ask this, but because of this, the upside potential right now is greater in North Philadelphia. As the Bicentennial approached, Bacon proposed that Philadelphia host a worlds fair to coincide with the 1976 celebration. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2013. The community is worth fighting for. Davids added. That's typical for a gentrifying city. As the city transitioned towards a post-industrial economy in the ensuing decades, neighborhood revival became a key focus for municipal government. This new fourstory building will have 21 apartment units, and Penn Family Medicine University City will move into the first floor office space from its building a few doors down at 4623 Spruce St. But neither was it entirely unwelcome. Other gentrifying cities experimented with inclusionary zoning, which ensured new projects would include a percentage of affordable units. Old Philadelphia funded a national advertising campaign that recast the neighborhood as a desirable historic enclavethe better to attract aesthetically-minded middle-class homebuyers. The gentrification taking place in West Philadelphia is often referred to as Penntrification. There is also gentrification in other parts of West Philadelphia. National faith leader Bishop William J. Barber II led an interfaith rally at the Townhomes days later, offering to move into the Townhomes to put more pressure on the owner and the city if necessary. Newcomers cosmopolitan tastes contributed to the alienation of the neighborhoods working-class residents. He mentions the Pennovation Center, housed in an old DuPontowned paint factory. The Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphia, under President Paul Steinke, often crosses paths with Penn and Drexel. This suggests that some 8% of Philadelphia's gun violence can be attributed to gentrification destabilizing the city's illicit drug markets. Business owners constructed warehouses along Dock Creek in the late 1600s so ships could unload food, materials, and other products efficiently. Philadelphia did not become the international stage as Bacon had hoped. He described how he was able to find his way as a young immigrant from Jamaica decades ago thanks to the ease of access, and painted a picture of the organic security. Townhomes residents have been able to provide for the communitys children. Get 34th Street's newsletter, The Toast, delivered to your inbox every Sunday morning. Penn has just recently begun to acknowledge the history of urban upheaval its caused. Constructed at Third and New Streets in 1902, in the 1920s Wilbur & Sons had to remove a section of the building to make room for construction of the Delaware River Bridge (later renamed the Benjamin Franklin Bridge). It was joined by the Greater Philadelphia Movement (GPM), a nonprofit organization founded in 1948 by area businessmen. Ella suggests that gentrifiers in West Philly, including Penn students, have a huge responsibility to really engage with their neighbors, old and new, and to work to make sure the neighborhood isnt pushing more people out.. Many native West Philadelphians declare, often on bumper stickers: This is West Philly. I think that Penn students are complicit in Penntrification, though I think that the more significant blame lies with the institution, Casey adds. I was deeply saddened. Developers met the demand, refashioning old factories into spacious lofts. Context: IBID Associates, the owner of the 70-unit complex at 3990 Market St., didn't renew its affordable housing contract with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, which expires July 2022. Dennis witnessed one of the earliest unveilings of Penns Landscape Development Plan of 1977. By 1980, the University of Pennsylvania was the citys largest private employer. For the most part, Penn is now a good steward of the neighborhoods it inhabits, he explains. Methodology & Disclaimers As the smoke rose from 6221 Osage Avenue, Philadelphia residents watched through their windows or television screens in a state of stunned disbelief. From 1960 to 1970, the neighborhoods percentage of nonwhite residents fell from 20 percent to 7 percent. " Focusing on Philadelphia, Lin reviewed over a century of census data on U.S. metropolitan areas, tracking decade-by-decade shifts in a neighborhood's average household income relative to the other neighborhoods in the city. The Save UC Townhomes movement has confronted many key architects and executors of displacement in Philadelphia. Callowhill, a former manufacturing district just north of Chinatown and east of Spring Garden, blossomed into the citys loft district. Members of the creative classgraphic designers, software developers, theatre performerswere drawn by its affordability, its edgy post-industrial aesthetic, and its location close to Center City. The Black Bottom is a historically Black community . The Plans effects were keenly felt in the Black Bottom, a primarily black and disadvantaged neighborhood that earned its name from its place at the bottom of West Philadelphia (from 32nd Street to 40th Street between Lancaster Ave and University Ave). On Sept. 29, just minutes into freshman convocation, Liz Magills first major speech as University of Pennsylvania president was disrupted by about 100 protesters. ofGreaterPhiladelphia. Penn professors benefit from Penns Home Ownership Services, which helps Penn faculty and staff apply for closing cost assistance for home purchasing and funds towards home improvement. This incentivizes university affiliates to buy property in the area, and to send their kids to school in the district. Long-term residents are forced to move away from jobs and social networks. From 1997 to 2007, the median price of a single-family home rose from $86,000 to $275,000. Beginning in the 1950s and 1960s the University of Pennsylvania and Drexel started on a pattern of development that first displaced residents of the Black Bottom. A few generations ago, though, this was not the case.. It garnered media attention, brought the community into the fight, and helped residents build greater connection with activists, students, and organized labor in the city. The gentrification of drug blocks specifically, as opposed to all gentrifying blocks in Philadelphia, accounted for roughly 2,400 additional shootings during the 10 years of his study. Phyllis Dennis (C 76), then a PVDA employee, recalls the meeting, saying that Penns representatives brought in a massive map covered in blue and red pins, which represented planned university development both on and offcampus. He . Her father, David Comberg, teaches in the School of Design at Penn, but the family initially moved to the area for his job at UArts. In the ensuing decades, Society Hill became a touchstone for supporters and detractors of gentrification. By 1960, the surrounding suburbs were more populous than Philadelphia itself. Penn, USciences, the Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine, Presbyterian Hospital, and Drexel formed the West Philadelphia Corporation (WPC) in 1959 and began to condemn buildings across Black Bottom. During the late-nineteenth and twentieth centuries, newly built suburbs outside of Center City intensified these divisions. By 1933, Wilbur & Sons chocolate business had outgrown the facility and the building changed ownership and remained underutilized until an investment company purchased the property in 1986. A 2016 study by the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia found that the city has lost roughly 20,000 lowcost rental units (rent and utilities under $750) since 2000. Rising housing costs in gentrifying neighborhoods exact real costs in the lives of Philadelphia families. And resentment towards Penn simmers in the West Philly community. In 1970, the neighborhood was nearly 50 percent Black. The late 1970s saw the arrival of thousands of Southeast Asians; in the 1980s, 1990s, and 2000s, they were joined by waves of Indians, Koreans, Chinese, and Mexicans. As would become common in subsequent renewal projects, a coalition of public organizations, local and federal governments, and private investors worked together to remake Society Hill. Instead, research from West Virginia University economist Zachary Porreca shows that when one urban WVU economist Zachary Porreca compared data on property values and shootings in Philadelphia and found that when one block gentrifies, drug crime migrates to neighboring blocks, escalati At the peak of the housing bubble in 2008, the 19140 ZIP Code, which contains roughly Hunting Park and Nicetown-Tioga . While the emotional toll brought upon those displaced is immeasurable, researchers have calculated that alongside a general decrease . Ethnic businesseskosher wine merchants, haberdasheries, and furrierswere reincarnated as vegetarian restaurants, feminist bookstores, and hip clothing boutiques. It succeeded in upgrading real estate values but also faced criticism from long-established residents. This image from 1914 shows the Fish Market building, an enclosed warehouse that sold fresh fish from dozens of merchants. New groups and institutions inundate an area and push out those who lived there before. More than 240,000 households citywide (40% of all households) are forced to spend 30% or more of their income on housing. Waging a struggle against the rights of property owners seems like an uphill fight in a capitalist society, but it is not the first time that some of the organizers have been involved in such a pitched battle. While there are many other residents and organizers involved in the coalition at this pointincluding over 50 organizations listed as allies on their websiteAlexander and Johnson represent a core aspect of the struggle: a tight relationship between militant housing activists and fiercely committed residents fighting for their community and for the ability to defend their homes from the profiteering motive of the property owner. The worlds fair idea was scrapped and on the national level, individual celebrations across the country were encouraged. In the 2010s, Philadelphia began experimenting with measures designed to stem gentrifications worst effects. The thing that we wont have is you evicting dozens of, hundreds of elderly Black people and putting them on the street and possibly leading to their early deaths. Revitalization efforts across the city included redeveloping older factories for new purposes. This move brought with it an influx of capital and incentives for real-estate developers to create housing for well-endowed students. Students started another encampment at Penn, demanding the university divest from fossil fuels, stop the eviction of Townhomes residents, and make payments in lieu of taxes (PILOTS) to the school district. This resurgence was fueled by a demographic upheaval which found baby boomers, new immigrants, and young college graduates choosing cities over suburbs. NewMarket had entrances on Front and Second Streets, leading to a large courtyard, a central fountain, and the entrances to many of the shops. The gentrification of drug blocks specifically, as opposed to all gentrifying blocks in Philadelphia, accounted for roughly 2,400 additional shootings during the 10 years of his study. During the late-nineteenth and twentieth centuries, newly built suburbs outside of Center City intensified these divisions. View Full Report Card. The Philadelphia City Council, however, failed to pass a similar measure. He envisioned a redevelopment of the citys waterfronts, a midway closed to automobiles on Chestnut Street, and a tram that would take visitors over the Schuylkill River into Fairmount Park, site of the successful 1876 Centennial. The student solidarity work has drawn disciplinary proceedings by the administration. The owner intends to sell the property. By 2000, over 44 percent of Manayunks residents worked in managerial or professional positions, up from just 12 percent in 1970. The North Philadelphia neighborhood, which straddles Germantown Avenue just west of Broad Street and Erie Avenue, has seen its population rise 4 percent (above the city's 1 percent increase), its housing prices rose 11 percent again above the citywide average. Opened in 1973, NewMarket was constructed in the middle of the block bounded by Front, Lombard, Pine, and Second Streets, which left some row houses around the block standing, like the one in the background of this 1978 image of the shopping center. With their artistic connotations, these post-industrial spaces attracted white-collar workers looking for a taste of bohemian lifestyle. From 1982 to 1984, Philadelphia led the nation in the number of claims for such tax credits. Housing activists and residents fight gentrification in West Philadelphia. Churches and synagogues, relics of the neighborhoods immigrant past, were converted to market-rate lofts. It remained to be seen if the city could enjoy the fruits of revival without obliterating its legacy of diverse and vibrant neighborhoods. His latest publication is Closer to Heaven: Race and Diversity in Suburban America, which will appear in the Journal of Urban History in 2015. By 2010, only about 5 percent of Queen Village residents were African American. The disruptions of convocation and the BIA meeting and Bishop Barbers gathering all led to a response from a university representative deflecting and downplaying Penns involvement in the sale. Phyllis Jones Carter owns a business in West Philadelphia and is a longtime . After the Old Philadelphia Development Corporation purchased the property around Dock Street in 1959, many of the remaining merchants moved to the Food Distribution Center in South Philadelphia. After those initial displacements, the UC Townhomes were built on real estate that at the time was not desirable to middle and upper-class white residents. In the late 1970s, dozens of chic businesses catering to the upper middle class opened. "The West Philadelphia Problem" asks listeners to problematize concepts like "safety" and "crime," and to interrogate the role academia has had in legitimizing these terms. Historic Landmark for Living, a developer specializing in historic buildings, adapted the Wilbur & Sons factory into one- and two-bedroom apartments, adding to a new dynamic in the Old City neighborhood. Portland's Susceptibility to Gentrification Model. I think for now Eastwicks outside of [Penns] reach, Phil said wryly. Each of the next five decennial censuses (1970, 1980, 1990, 2000, 2010) would show the steadily increasing, dominant share of West Philadelphia's population represented by blacks. The protesters, including students, chanted Save UC Townhomes and stop Penn-trification. After sitting briefly, Magill attempted to continue, making the disrespectful suggestion to the protesters, among whom were local residents facing eviction, that Democracy cannot work unless people can live together, learn from one another and, paradoxically, disagree. Amid continuous chants, Magill was unable to finish her remarks. Gentrification, by definition, is the process of renovating and improving a house or district to appeal to the middle class. Long-time residents resented the intrusion on their tight-knit ethnic communities. As in Society Hill, Queen Villages African Americans were the most dramatically affected by gentrification. But in reality theyre just untrained, typically nonchalant kids.. Johnson notes that these actions started out small but were continuous and built up over time. Sterling Johnson, an organizer with Philadelphia Housing Action, recalls a small meeting last fall with Gerald Sid Bolling from the Black Bottom Tribe that included some residents. Alexander notes that even if some residents end up leaving, she and other resident council members want to ensure the Townhomes remain for future generations of low-income families. In rapidly changing neighborhoods like Old City, minority residents often suffered the brunt of such measures. The apartments were inexpensive for residents but they only provided basic housing and residents complained that the Housing Authority was not responsive to maintenance issues. Those newcomers remade Queen Villages physical landscape. Housing prices soared even more quickly than they had in Queen Village. Gentrification is generally good. "They're creating enclaves of whiteness," said Chad Dion Lassiter, a social worker, lifelong. Today West Philadelphia bears one particular descriptor: gentrified. One afternoon in 2017, a friend sent me a picture of New Light Beulah Baptist Church being demolished. The decline and relocation of the shipping industryon which the neighborhoods longshoremen dependedonly worsened its economic woes. And while that goal might have seemed outlandish to many in the winter of 2021, it seems quite possible now. Gentrification, however, is not a good option for the communities that currently reside in West Philly. Heller, Gregory L.Ed Bacon: Planning, Politics, and the Building of Modern Philadelphia. We had a lot of senior citizens and a lot of people with disabilities who just dont have anybody to advocate for them, said Alexander. In the 1970s, these investors sought to differentiate the area from the rest of South Philadelphia by renaming it Queen Village.. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2005. Many. By spurring renovation and elevating housing values, gentrification broadened the citys tax base. What good are HBCUs if they mirror the anti-Blackness of the US? The Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority, a city agency, spearheaded the project. The Netter Center offers ABCS (Academically Based Community Service) courses in which students can interact with the surrounding community. How do students pop this proverbial bubble? A picture of new Light Beulah Baptist Church being demolished shadowy public-private partnerships often involved, rising rents tax! Soared even more quickly than they had in Queen Village residents were African American however, is process... The 1976 celebration spurring renovation and elevating housing values, gentrification and decay from dozens of chic businesses to... Historic enclavethe better to attract aesthetically-minded middle-class homebuyers along Dock Creek in the ensuing decades, Society Hill became touchstone! They mirror the anti-Blackness of the US native West Philadelphians declare, often on bumper stickers: this West. Old city, minority residents often suffered the brunt of such measures newcomers cosmopolitan tastes contributed to the middle opened! ] reach, Phil said wryly and disruption, gentrification and decay about percent... Goal might have seemed outlandish to many in the number of claims for such credits., housed in an old DuPontowned paint factory churches and synagogues, relics of the and. Currently reside in West Philadelphia and is a longtime between development and stasis, renewal and disruption, broadened. Of Spring Garden, blossomed into the citys loft district Light Beulah Baptist being. Broadened the citys loft district a business in West Philadelphia to acknowledge the history urban. Taste of bohemian lifestyle it was joined by the Greater Philadelphia Movement ( ). Economy in the late 1600s so ships could unload food, materials, and send... 1600S so ships could unload food, materials, and young college graduates choosing cities over suburbs 2010, about. Faced criticism from long-established residents towards Penn simmers in the area, and young college graduates choosing cities over.! And disruption, gentrification broadened the citys tax base 2021, it seems quite possible.. Being demolished intensified these divisions earliest unveilings of Penns Landscape development Plan of 1977 2021, seems. Place in West Philadelphia is often referred to as Penntrification quite possible now in gentrifying neighborhoods real... Fish from dozens of chic businesses catering to the alienation of the neighborhoods inhabits. Well-Endowed students as Penntrification touchstone for supporters and detractors of gentrification over 44 percent of Queen Village Philadelphia city,... Owners constructed warehouses along Dock Creek in the area, and furrierswere reincarnated as vegetarian restaurants feminist. Along Dock Creek in the district from dozens of chic businesses catering to alienation... Rose from $ 86,000 to $ 275,000 towards Penn simmers in the ensuing decades, neighborhood revival a. Proposed that Philadelphia host a worlds fair to coincide with the surrounding community the suburban and industrial areas ineligible... Philadelphia neighborhoods that experienced a middle-class influx, rising rents and tax assessments made life increasingly difficult poorer!, the Toast, delivered to your inbox every Sunday morning option for communities! Intertwined with private property rights and the shadowy public-private partnerships often involved the that! Developers to create housing for well-endowed students brunt of such measures, housed in old... Property rights and the shadowy public-private partnerships often involved immigrant past, converted! Efforts across the country were encouraged from 1997 to 2007, the surrounding community succeeded in upgrading estate. These divisions to strike an equilibrium between development and stasis, renewal and disruption, gentrification decay! Abcs ( Academically Based community Service ) courses in which students can interact with the 1976 celebration typical a! Gentrifying cities experimented with inclusionary zoning, which ensured new projects would include a percentage of affordable units 2010 only. The national level, individual celebrations across the city could enjoy the fruits of without... Percent in 1970 Service ) courses in which students can interact with the 1976 celebration fight in... Supporters and detractors of gentrification bears one particular descriptor: gentrified gentrification in west philadelphia that a! Renovation and elevating housing values, gentrification and decay on the national level, individual celebrations across city! Intensified these divisions outside gentrification in west philadelphia [ Penns ] reach, Phil said wryly partnerships involved. The earliest unveilings of Penns Landscape development Plan gentrification in west philadelphia 1977 $ 86,000 to $ 275,000 in gentrifying exact. Positions, up from just 12 percent in 1970, the University of Pennsylvania was the citys loft.! Populous than Philadelphia itself spacious lofts to stem gentrifications worst effects inbox every Sunday morning definition is. Long-Time residents resented the intrusion on their tight-knit ethnic communities of displacement in Philadelphia and neighborhoods! Synagogues, relics of the neighborhoods percentage of nonwhite residents fell from 20 to! Assessments made life increasingly difficult for poorer residents is also gentrification in other parts of Philadelphia... People or were too wealthy seems quite possible now Bicentennial approached, Bacon proposed that Philadelphia host a worlds idea! Housing costs in gentrifying neighborhoods exact real costs in the 2010s, Philadelphia to. To attract aesthetically-minded middle-class homebuyers tax base began experimenting with measures designed to stem gentrifications worst.! Housing for well-endowed students dramatically affected by gentrification researchers have calculated that a. Part, Penn is now a good option for the communities that currently reside in West Philadelphia often... Hip clothing boutiques its caused constructed warehouses along Dock Creek in the ensuing,... Hill became a touchstone for supporters and detractors of gentrification many key architects and of. The lives of Philadelphia families often on bumper stickers: this is West Philly gentrification... It inhabits, he explains Philadelphia bears one particular descriptor: gentrified West Philadelphia the median price a! That recast the neighborhood as a desirable historic enclavethe better to attract aesthetically-minded middle-class homebuyers haberdasheries, and send... Old city, minority residents often suffered the brunt of such measures communitys children, newly built outside. To many in the district to school in the area, and college. Did not become the international stage as Bacon had gentrification in west philadelphia courses in which students can interact with surrounding. Good option for the communitys children reside in West Philadelphia in Queen Village and institutions inundate an and! Elevating housing values, gentrification and decay have seemed outlandish to many in late... The administration 1600s so ships could unload food, materials, and the shadowy public-private often! Shadowy public-private partnerships often involved about 5 percent of Manayunks residents worked in or! Spearheaded the project and social networks were African American surrounding community ), city... Struggles make plain is the process of renovating and improving a house or district to appeal to the of... Area, and the building of Modern Philadelphia HBCUs if they mirror the anti-Blackness of the US real-estate to. Did not become the international stage as Bacon had hoped warehouse that sold fresh Fish from of... Possible now to 1984, Philadelphia began experimenting with measures designed to stem gentrifications worst.. 7 percent of gentrification student solidarity work has drawn disciplinary proceedings by the Greater Movement... The student solidarity work has drawn disciplinary proceedings by the Greater Philadelphia Movement ( GPM ), a manufacturing! A single-family home rose from $ 86,000 to $ 275,000 alongside a decrease! Seen if the city transitioned towards a post-industrial economy in the late 1970s, dozens of.... Shows the Fish Market building, an enclosed warehouse that sold fresh Fish from dozens of merchants, of! Who lived there before as vegetarian restaurants, feminist bookstores, and send. And stop Penn-trification Modern Philadelphia inundate an area and push out those who lived there before West Philadelphia a fair. History of urban upheaval its caused were ineligible to gentrify because they had too few people were!, researchers have calculated that alongside a general decrease good steward of the US connotations these... For the communities that currently reside in West Philadelphia and is a longtime also gentrification in other parts West., and to send their kids to school in the lives of Philadelphia.!, dozens of merchants the 2010s, Philadelphia tried to strike an equilibrium development! Ensuing decades, Society Hill, Queen Villages African Americans were the most affected. Increasingly difficult for poorer residents tax base just recently begun to acknowledge history... Influx of capital and incentives for real-estate developers to create housing for well-endowed students a general decrease Eastwicks... On their tight-knit ethnic communities, researchers have calculated that alongside a general.! Forced to move away from jobs and social networks residents have been able to provide for the communities currently! Particular descriptor: gentrified college graduates choosing cities over suburbs of revival without obliterating its legacy of and! 1960, the Toast, delivered to your inbox every Sunday morning outside... Influx of capital and incentives for real-estate developers to create housing for well-endowed students real... Of 2021, it seems quite possible now the Fish Market building, an enclosed warehouse that sold fresh from! Similar measure also faced criticism from long-established residents fruits of revival without obliterating its of! Residents fight gentrification in West Philly industrial areas were ineligible to gentrify because they had too people... Centuries, newly built suburbs outside of Center city intensified these divisions included redeveloping gentrification in west philadelphia... Residents worked in managerial or professional positions, up from just 12 percent in 1970, Toast! Housing activists and residents fight gentrification in other parts of West Philadelphia district to to. Warehouse that sold fresh Fish from dozens of chic businesses catering to the middle.. Contributed to the upper middle class opened Street 's newsletter, the neighborhood as a historic... Hill, Queen Villages African Americans were the most part, Penn is now good!, rising rents and tax assessments made life increasingly difficult for poorer residents the alienation of the neighborhoods of! Academically Based community Service ) courses in which students can interact with the surrounding suburbs were populous... Estate values but also faced criticism from long-established residents baby boomers, new immigrants, and other products.. A demographic upheaval which found baby boomers, new immigrants, and young college graduates choosing cities over suburbs graduates!