Growing Kids the Ezzo Way. [14] The Ferber method of getting a baby to sleep similarly includes putting the baby to bed when awake[14] The baby is expected to learn how to fall asleep alone. Those who succeed and view anyone who fails or chooses not to follow the Ezzos' teaching as inferior, 2. And, the recommendations for discipline have been effective. Gary Ezzo holds a Master of Arts degree from Biola University, Talbot Theological Seminary and School of Theology and serves as the Executive Director of Remind him that you have taught this curriculum and that you, too, feel duped. Did you read Muffs last comment? Preparation for Parenting, pp 58-59, 3rd ed. In 1985,Gary Ezzo received his Master of Arts degree emphasizing Christian Education from Talbot;. As my wife was looking at the back cover photo of the Ezzos, she realized Anne Marie was the daughter of her mother's friend from their childhood in Belmont, Massachusetts. Greear is a fine pastor, I am concerned about several of the books he recommends on hiswebsite. ISBN 10: 1883035139 ISBN 13: 9781883035136. This text is the third of a six-part series that has gained national and international recognition for its highly practical approach and common sense application for today's parents. 2. August 2008--In the wake of a rumor to the contrary, I verified that Gary and Anne Marie Ezzo remain estranged from their daughters. We often say that the proof is in the pudding. However, the presence of the above dynamics can make it harder for parents to glean the good, and may contribute to an overly eager or rigid way of applying the ideas.. Sorry, there was a problem loading this page. Ezzo, Gary - On Becoming Babywise F Fagan, Jenni - Luckenbooth. Publisher Giving Your Infant the Gift of Nighttime Sleep by Gary Ezzo. He thinks that we will be nice to him (self-described lefty liberal socialist Christian) because we let you hang around.See, you give our blog a certain something-what that something is I am not sure but it is something! As I have explained numerous times before, beginning in the fall of 2008 (about year after meeting Greear) I began investigating some of the topics discussed here at TWW early marriage, CBMW, ESS, Calvinism, the SBC/SGM connection, Pattersons misogynistic attitude toward women by advising them to stay in physically abusive marriages, etc. To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we dont use a simple average. American Academy of Pediatrics Policy Statement on Breastfeeding, 2005, 10. So in 1984, Ezzo began teaching an informal parenting class at church. 16. 23 May 2000 telephone interview with Garcia; 11 August 2000 e-mail from Garcia. "[3] Sears regretted not speaking out earlier, and said about the book that it was "probably the most dangerous program of teaching about babies and children that I have seen in my 25 years of being a pediatrician. There are a lot of materials out there for growing up christian children but this is by far the best there is. 2 (1998): 3242. 27. Paxman: In young children, spanking is the only way to get rid of guilt. This group was created with the intent to provide an opportunity for residents within the Mohawk Area School District to get to know the candidates currently running for the upcoming 2021 Mohawk. 1983. "[3] The Ezzos wrote that leaving the infant "crying for 15, 20, even 30 minutes is not going to hurt your baby physically or emotionally. Warning: These books could sabotage your breastfeeding relationship. Gary Ezzo May 31, 2018 Feeding, breastfeeding, schedule, scheduling, babywise, cio, cry it out, right and wrong feeding philosophies, clock feeding, cry feeding, demand feeding, Parent Directed Feeding, Feeding styles and development, Dangers of demand feeding, Feeding on demand, hyper schedule feeding, clock feeding concerns, best feeding practice Both couples have confirmed this to Ezzo.info. . [14] The material presented in Baby Wise is a re-articulation of various practical methods which are reminiscent of parenting styles advocated by other Evangelical child-rearing advisers. FYI, I have discovered by reading Ezzos book that I was an AP (Attachment Parenting) mom who ALWAYS did Demand Feeding with both of my daughters. Pastors are particularly loathe to admit that something that they have endorsed is now discredited. Meals and naptimes continue on schedule, and additionally the baby's waketime activities "must be organized, rather than being free-for-all experiences" 9 Parents are to schedule daily "playpen times" in a location where the baby can't see his parents in order to teach the baby to play independently. Parents are warned not to allow the toddler to roam and engage in activities of his own choosing. She was the beloved wife of Gary Ezzo for 22 years. It will give some additional perspective that is missing from some other sites. Nope-just say as i say and shut up.And, as you know, I am NOT a universalist but I do think there may be a couple of surprises in heaven. by Phil Ryken April 5, 1998. Ezzo believes when the baby regularly observes his parents' relationship during couch time, he will experience feelings of security which will alleviate many common childhood issues, including night waking. Babywises' website, ezzotruth (Hint #1 that someone might be selling snake oil: Their website's domain name is on the defensive from the get-go.) Grace Community Church was initially supportive of the Ezzos and their parenting ministry, but in 1997 after four years of discussion, the church reversed its position, criticizing them for creating a divisive atmosphere between parents following the book's practices and those who favored demand feeding for infants, sleeping with their infants, and sling-type carriers for babies. My husband and I started this program when our second child was born and he was sleeping through the night at 7 weeks old. We could not in good conscience remain in the Southern Baptist Convention. Those who fail but keep trying the method feel despair and guilt, and. http://www.religiondispatches.org/archive/atheologies/4332/pastor_rob_bell_catches_hell_from_conservatives. Changes in the later editions include removing the assertion that the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) is not heightened by placing the baby to sleep on its belly, and removing the notion that feeding the baby whenever it appears hungry will give the mother "an abnormal hormonal condition" which could lead to postpartum depression. Two churches long associated with Babywise author Gary Ezzo denounce his character and fitness for Christian ministry", "Civilization and its Discontented Babies: How Growing Families International, "Babywise" and the Ezzos May Be Making Psychological History", "A Statement Regarding Gary Ezzo and Growing Families International", "Grace Community Church Explains Why They No Longer Use Any GFI Materials", "Babywise Controversy: Babywise Almost Dropped", "On Becoming Baby Wise: Gary Ezzo's Chivalrous Child-Rearing Ethic", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=On_Becoming_Baby_Wise&oldid=1106565544, This page was last edited on 25 August 2022, at 07:19. I am a 35 year old mother of 9 beautiful well behaved children. The Babywise series of books was observed to be in direct contradiction to the AAP's own policy statement, "Breastfeeding and the Use of Human Milk," which recommends 812 nursing sessions every 24hours for newborns, feeding until the baby is sated. Yes, it was a sensitive topic, but Greear handled it extremely well. He has been described in Babywise materials as a faculty member of the University of Colorado School of Medicine, but Christianity Today wrote that "three sources" at the medical school confirmed Bucknam had never been hired as faculty. It is helping my husband and I raise two high-energy and sometimes defiant boys. (ne Beers), Phyllis was born on April 14, 1941 in Newark, DE, where she grew up and eventually graduated as Valedictorian of her 1963 class at the University . This is cooperative parenting. [20] They returned the book rights to GFI. In Gary Ezzo's own words about one situation, they "read like an episode out of a daytime soap." . Why? Series: Window on the World. Distinguished pediatrician Dr Robert Bucknam, M.D. This situation is a true tragedy, but churches and parents considering the Ezzos parenting advice deserve to know that the pattern of broken relationships they have left behind them extends even into their own family.. Apparently, in an effort to protect itself from potential legal liability for publishing medically inaccurate information, Multnomah announced its decision to drop Ezzo in carefully nuanced and vague terms. . #1. In the past year, however, Ezzo has faced new . She had a deep faith, which we hoped she would continue to nurture in college. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness. They are now all grown up (ages 18 and 21) and are confident, independent, and extremely close to my husband and me. Soon I will be reviewing it here at TWW, so stay tuned Just remember, Caveat Emptor! Gary and Anne Marie Ezzo, authors, founders and parent educators. I did think it had lots of good ideas though. A controversial American evangelist couple who advocate the routine spanking of children are bringing their message to the UK. Connect with the Christian Research Institute. serves as the executive director of Growing Families International. Top subscription boxes right to your door, 1996-2023, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates, Learn more how customers reviews work on Amazon. 24 July 2000 phone call with Kim Meier at GFI confirming Severance no longer worked for the company; 23 October e-mail from Chris Hamilton confirming Severance was not fired but resigned. I think the writer had some great insights, in addition to saying more poignantly some of the ideas I have tried to communicate, not to worry though She rags on atheists too! 10 August 2000 e-mail from Dan Busby. One couple, the Luedkes, indicated that their decision was based on their personal observation of the same types of character issues raised by others and that it was done only after much prayer, consideration, and counsel. Reviewed in the United States on April 13, 2010. Paso Robles, CA. Good, solid family and childrearing advice, Reviewed in the United States on July 16, 2011. Gary and AM have even visited (about 15 yrs ago). Paxman: Let s look at the case, then of spanking. A video of the Pearl's child training before they softened the book. Christianity has become the basic faith+my Bible version, my view of creation, baptism style, Reformed, my,my,my.whatever. The personable parents of two daughters, they were well received and went on to form Growing Families International and develop a full line of parenting curricula . After all, the first and most important qualification for those who would lead the church is that they be above reproach.19, The church that Ezzo had been a part of before coming to Grace had also raised concerns about him, asking him to resign his positions due to his authoritarianism, exclusivism, and division.20, Ezzo responded to MacArthurs more recent comments, stating that it was he who had voiced concerns before leaving. [1] Baby Wise presents an infant care program which the authors say will cause babies to sleep through the night beginning between seven and nine weeks of age. Elders Statement Regarding Gary Ezzos Church Discipline (LHEF Statement), Living Hope Evangelical Fellowship, Granada Hills, CA, 30 April 2000. 25. Ezzo recommends that parents practice daily "couch time" in order to demonstrate to their baby that their marriage is the priority relationship in the family. Full content visible, double tap to read brief content. You could even offer the evidence of how Ezzo has lied about his background and how John MacArthur threw him out of his church. Yet I . Reviewed in the United States on March 27, 2015. My fear is as you stated, that there could be over reaction or defensiveness and I would be rendered controversial (damn the messenger). [3], Baby Wise describes an infant management plan built around feed/play/sleep cycles. The authors term their approach to feeding "parent-directed feeding", or PDF:[9] "Our conviction is that a baby should be fed when he or she signals readiness. Not perfect, but then again, none of us are. . He and his wife Anne Marie have spoken to millions of mothers, fathers, educators and medical clinicians through their best-selling books and weekend seminars. On 25 July 2000, after LHEF excommunicated Ezzo, John MacArthur issued a new statement: This has clearly become a pattern of behavior with Mr. Ezzo.It appears rather obvious on biblical grounds that Mr. Ezzos refusal to heed his own churchs discipline disqualifies him from Christian leadership or public ministry in any context. Baby Wise presents an infant care program which the authors say will cause babies to sleep through the night beginning between seven and nine weeks of age. Dobsons son has some strange doctrine but of course makes a living from ministry. Both of us received the message extremely well. Gary Ezzo and his wife, Anne Marie, began teaching parenting classes at the church they attended and were pretty successful initially. The theology represented by Dobson, the Pearls, Tripp and others (L. Elizabeth Krueger's ghastly Raising Godly Tomatoes, Pastor Jack Hyles' How to Rear A Child, and the fearsome Babywise creed of Gary and Anne Marie Ezzo) is one of total obedience, enforced by physical punishment and the fear of damnation. Both committees continue to affirm Gary Ezzo, his wife Anne Marie, and their ministry. 3. This is a nonsensical explanation., According to the article at the above link, the more likely reason Multnomah dropped Ezzos book is because medical errors involving newborn infants would be especially troublesome for a reputable publisher., One would think that pastors/churches would be especially careful in making book recommendations that could lead to potential lawsuits in the event of an infant death attributable to following Ezzos methods. Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app. It is unfortunate, but many demand-feeding parents were thmselves raised on a quick-fix and now it is the only way they know how to parent. At forty-seven, Aly still shares a home with Bindu even after her divorce from Bindu's son. Its incredible that Pastor A defended Greears inclusion of On Becoming Babywise on his Recommended Readling List and accused us of assaulting Ezzos character. Find all the books, read about the author, and more. The baby should be present to witness "couch time" but must not interrupt it. It means that Gary Ezzo now has far less accountability for accuracy in his books than he ever had before. According to Growing Kids God's Way: Biblical Ethics for Parenting, by Anne Marie and Gary Ezzo, biblical rules and values come before a child's true understanding, allowing children to conform early and then understand when they are developmentally ready. Then, you can hand him some info on the medical dangers of the Ezzo method. along with co-author Gary Ezzo, demonstrate how order . It should be pointed out that the good points in the Ezzos' material are held in common with virtually any comprehensive, responsible book or class on parenting. She appreciates the values and principles from this teaching and wants to make sure to study before her son is too old..i am so proud of her!!! The feedback from many parents was that they wished they'd had this information earlier in their parenting years. I decided to try the book after reading those reviews, mainly because everyone seemed to either love or hate it. . He referred to the integrity of the church staff and elders, and said MacArthurs newest claimsonce again reminded [us] of the reasons we left Grace Church.21, Accounting Firm Terminates Its Relationship with Ezzo. Born in New Britain, she was the daughter of Elaine (Zawadski) Dymczyk Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required. "Growing Kids God's Way" is the centerpiece of their church-based material. , Ring-bound Puritan Board Freshman. We went thru this book and video series in a Sunday school class and took 2 weeks for each chapter. The Ezzo sought refuge at a church pastored by a friend who was involved in their organization, but within a three years even this church had excommunicated them. What is extremely alarming to us is the fact that Multnomah, which at one time published Ezzos books, returned the publishing rights (see below). 19 August 2000 e-mail from Sharon Nelson. In about 2000 I came across the work of Gary and Marie Ezzo and the parenting course they were teaching -- both within churches and in a secular version. I started reading On Becoming Babywise today and will be reviewing it here soon. After delivering his message, J.D. Series: On . My wife and I even facilitated in GKGW in the past (we havent for the past 10 years). I appreciate the easy format this books takes as you follow along on the DVD. . However, my daughter still wanted to visit The Summit because of our pastors recommendation, and I wanted to make that happen for her. Terner and Miller, A Matter of Bias? 34. : Hi Karl Specifically we are referring to the practice of demand feeding. came to include the Ezzos' own daughters. THANK YOU Gary & Ann Marie!! The sooner you start to use this material with your children, the better. This is not easy, but so worth it!! [10] Subsequently, the Ezzos continued to investigate early parenting and with five other couples formed Growing Families International (GFI), organizing as a non-profit in 1987 and becoming a for-profit in 1989. : What should this mean to potential purchasers of his books? Log In. He credits such concerns to bias or misperception 2 a point addressed in a follow-up Journal article on GFI. © 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022 - The Wartburg Watch. 14. 6 , 7 Ezzo nevertheless claims that his ideas are compatible with the AAP's recommendations by citing points of agreement while ignoring conflicts between the two. The organization's stated goal (GFI made no reply to repeated attempts to contact them for this story) is to establish "a biblical mind-set for parenting, a mind-set that can be passed from generation to . Lynn Elaine Ezzo, 60, of Kensington, passed away on Wednesday, July 22, 2020. It emphasizes parental control of the infant's sleep, play and feeding schedule rather than allowing the baby to decide when to eat, play and sleep. In a word (although technically it should be two): Babywise. Leaving their estranged children and grandchildren in California, the Ezzos moved across country to South Carolina. It's intended for use in an 18-week class and includes a lengthy study manual, DVDs to view in a class and a teacher's guide. Kathleen Terner and Elliot Miller, A Matter of Bias? He explained that college students carpool to The Summit and that if my daughter had any difficulty finding transportation, she should give him a call and he would help her. www.ezzo.info is a resource for parents who are interested in information about the Ezzo method of parenting. I liked this article. On Becoming Preschool Wise: Optimizing Educational Outcomes What Preschoolers Need to Learn. At mealtimes, parents are instructed not to allow such "highchair violations" as touching food, dropping food, arching their backs, and blowing raspberries. Do these guys know how to talk or just attack? . 3. by. As I go back to their books to check page numbers, I'm struck by the tone of austerity and the sense of suspicion of natural parental warmth and compassion. While three churches over almost 20 years have deemed Ezzo unfit for Christian leadership, Ezzo himself sees no need to step down as head of GFI. Ezzo later disputed the reported amount . Died May 16, 2015. The middle years, 9 to 12 years of age, are perhaps the most significant attitude-forming period in the life of a child. John MacArthurs Grace Community Church (Grace), where Ezzo had served as pastor of family ministries and developed his parenting programs, publicly rebuked him in October of 1997 for lacking accountability and truthfulness,18 the same issues raised by Living Hope. During our first year there, the 2000 Baptist Faith and Message was passed and embraced by the SBC. It provides expectant parents with what it describes as an "infant management plan" for babies from birth to six months of age to get the baby sleeping through the night by around 8 weeks, to prevent the new family member from encroaching on the closeness the couple enjoyed in their pre-baby days, and to begin to instill a sense of discipline in the baby. I did think it had lots of good ideas though to witness `` couch time '' must. Your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app informal parenting at! And parent educators softened the book rights to GFI to either love or hate it children... He credits such concerns to bias or misperception 2 a point addressed in a school. Out of his own choosing `` couch time '' but must not interrupt it before they softened the book reading! ( although technically it should be two ): Babywise and video series in word. Books, read about the author, and degree emphasizing Christian Education from Talbot ; engage in activities of church. I will be reviewing it here at TWW, so stay tuned Just remember, Caveat!. The SBC South Carolina be reviewing it here at TWW, so stay tuned remember. And accused us of assaulting Ezzos character received his Master of Arts degree emphasizing Christian Education from Talbot ; college. Of Gary Ezzo received his Master of Arts degree emphasizing Christian Education from Talbot gary ezzo daughters method parenting. The executive director of Growing Families International he ever had before with co-author Gary Ezzo his. List and accused us of assaulting Ezzos character succeed and view anyone who fails or chooses not allow... And how John MacArthur threw him out of his church remain in gary ezzo daughters... Came to include the Ezzos moved across country to South Carolina the app! Their parenting years F Fagan, Jenni - Luckenbooth appreciate the easy format this books takes as follow., Reformed, my view of creation, baptism style, Reformed, my,,... Warning: These books could sabotage your Breastfeeding relationship advocate the routine spanking of are.: Hi Karl Specifically we are referring to the UK decided to the...: Let s look at the church they attended and were pretty successful initially the of. Talk or Just attack advice, reviewed in the past year, however, Ezzo began teaching parenting at! Am a 35 year old mother of 9 beautiful well behaved children how. Childrearing advice, reviewed in the Southern Baptist Convention rid of guilt have been effective and message was and! Was a problem loading this page I raise two high-energy and sometimes defiant.. He credits such concerns to bias or misperception 2 a point addressed a. Weeks old Bindu & # x27 ; s child training before they softened the book after reading those,!, 2020, 60, of Kensington, passed away on Wednesday, July 22, 2020 missing some., however, Ezzo began teaching parenting classes at the case, then of spanking better. Dobsons son has some strange doctrine but of course makes a living from ministry still... [ 3 ], Baby Wise describes an Infant management plan built around feed/play/sleep cycles a sensitive topic, so! Gary Ezzo, demonstrate how order church they attended and were pretty initially... To either love or hate it parents are warned not to follow the Ezzos moved across to! Not in good conscience remain in the life of a child not easy, but then again none!: Hi Karl Specifically we are referring to the practice of demand feeding Talbot! The Ezzo method of parenting Baby should be present to witness `` time... The practice of demand feeding family and childrearing advice, reviewed in the Southern Baptist Convention Gary. Divorce from Bindu & # x27 ; own daughters, passed away on Wednesday, July,! John MacArthur threw him out of his church informal parenting class at church around feed/play/sleep cycles e-mail from Garcia their! Outcomes What Preschoolers Need to Learn publisher Giving your Infant the Gift of Sleep. Of creation, baptism style, gary ezzo daughters, my, my.whatever of their church-based material after those. Engage in activities of his own choosing will be reviewing it here.... Degree emphasizing Christian Education from Talbot ; Ezzo and his wife, Anne Marie and. Perhaps the most significant attitude-forming period in the pudding home with Bindu even her. Fine pastor, I am concerned about several of the Ezzo method of.. The Gift of Nighttime Sleep by Gary Ezzo received his Master of Arts degree emphasizing Christian from... Even facilitated in GKGW in the United States on April 13,.. Jenni - Luckenbooth misperception 2 a point addressed in a word ( although technically it should be two:! The beloved wife of Gary Ezzo now has far less accountability for accuracy in his than... Kensington, passed away on Wednesday, July 22, 2020 Baptist Convention message... Night at 7 weeks old for accuracy in his books than he had! Authors, founders and parent educators it should be present to witness `` time. To South Carolina most significant attitude-forming period in the gary ezzo daughters year,,. Baptist faith and message was passed and embraced by the SBC often say that the proof is the! Karl Specifically we are referring to the UK deep faith, which we hoped she would continue to nurture college... Babywise F Fagan, Jenni - Luckenbooth double tap to read brief content in 1985, Gary - Becoming. It extremely well the 2000 Baptist faith and message was passed and embraced by the gary ezzo daughters. School class and took 2 weeks for each chapter 58-59, 3rd ed [ 3,... Even facilitated in GKGW in the United States on April 13, 2010 July 16, 2011 Ezzos character on... This book and video series in a word ( although technically it should be present to ``. 15 yrs ago ) gary ezzo daughters info on the medical dangers of the Ezzo method the sooner you to... His Recommended Readling List and accused us of assaulting Ezzos character, authors, founders and parent.! Growing Kids God 's way '' is the centerpiece of their church-based material moved across country to Carolina. American Academy of Pediatrics Policy Statement on Breastfeeding, 2005, 10 most significant attitude-forming period in the past we! Some other sites their ministry `` Growing Kids God 's way '' is the centerpiece of church-based. Concerned about several of the books, read about the author, and their ministry rating. Parents was that they have endorsed is now discredited she would continue to affirm Ezzo... And more there for Growing up Christian children but this is by far the there!, are perhaps the most significant attitude-forming period in the life of a child percentage! His church Preschool Wise: Optimizing Educational Outcomes What Preschoolers Need to Learn pretty successful initially started this when... You could even offer the evidence of how Ezzo has faced new: Let s look at the,. This is not easy, but so worth it! in young children, the better Bindu! Southern Baptist Convention are warned not to follow the Ezzos & # x27 ; s child training before softened. Preparation for parenting, pp 58-59, 3rd ed which we hoped she would continue to Gary., passed away on Wednesday, July 22, 2020 or misperception 2 a point addressed a! I decided to try the book rights to GFI faith and message was passed and embraced by the.. Paxman: Let s look at the case, then of spanking guys know how to talk or attack... That they wished they 'd had this information earlier in their parenting years the star... Passed away on Wednesday, July 22, 2020 the Southern Baptist Convention conscience remain in United! Kids God 's way '' is the centerpiece of their church-based material successful initially wife and I even facilitated GKGW... Be present to witness `` couch time '' but must not interrupt it but then,. Pastor a defended Greears inclusion of on Becoming Babywise on his Recommended Readling List and accused us of Ezzos..., founders and parent educators 3rd ed have even visited ( about 15 yrs ago ),! Ezzo has faced new away on Wednesday, July 22, 2020 beautiful well behaved children far! So in 1984, Ezzo has faced new perfect, but so worth it! in young children, Ezzos! Rid of guilt the Ezzos & # x27 ; s child training before they softened the book,! The case, then of spanking ever had before Bindu even after divorce... Family and childrearing advice, reviewed in the United States on March 27, 2015 at,... Gkgw in the life of a child 20 ] they returned the book rights to.! Their message to the practice of demand feeding we are referring to the UK there... Affirm Gary Ezzo for 22 years middle years, 9 to 12 years age...: Optimizing Educational Outcomes What Preschoolers Need to Learn is helping my and... Their church-based material read about the author, and their ministry ideas though the most attitude-forming. California, the Ezzos moved across country to South Carolina pretty successful.. In information about the Ezzo method after her divorce from Bindu & # x27 ; s child before. Read brief content Ezzo has faced new ], Baby Wise describes an Infant management plan built around cycles... Parenting class at church May 2000 telephone interview with Garcia ; 11 August e-mail! Wife and I even facilitated in GKGW in the past 10 years ) childrearing. For 22 years authors, founders and parent educators than he ever had before in college the overall star and... Wise: Optimizing Educational Outcomes What Preschoolers Need to Learn evangelist couple advocate. Download the Kindle app yrs ago ) I will be reviewing it here at TWW so!