. As for my account of my argument with Nicole, Ive tried to make it as accurate as I possibly could. At least forty years ago, I think. Once that happens, we will become cognitive cyborgs, effectively incapable of misremembering anything. When Deirdre fact-checked her husbands previous statements, she was posing explicit queries to Remem. I want to point out there were a few written languages in africa (like nsibidi n is now called Nigeria), anyway an interesting story. I called Nicole and left a message saying I wanted to talk to her, and asking if I could come over to her apartment that evening. Spend some time using Remem, and youll find out. But if youre the type of person whos constantly trying to prove that youre right and your spouse is wrong, then your marriage is going to be in trouble whether you use Remem or not.". Ted Chiang is an American speculative fiction writer. What makes you think that? ", "But if lineage is so important, how can the elders from the west argue that the Shangev clan ought to join with the Jechira clan? Millions of people, some my age but most younger, have been keeping lifelogs for years, wearing personal cams that capture continuous video of their entire lives. Ive made mistakes." ", "What it says is important. "Cant you tell the Europeans about this? While facts are an important . Once he found the one he wanted, he could hold on to it for as long as he needed, Out of curiosity, Jijingi tried imagining he had to deliver a sermon, and began writing down what he would say. I asked Remem to examine the videos watermark, and it reported the video was unmodified. "But they did! When it comes to our individual memories, I live on the opposite side of the divide. Instead he said, "If you told it as you did before, you would say the Uyengi captured the women and children and carried them off as slaves every time. "Fucking typical. Even if each of us could have refrained from throwing the others bad behavior in their faces, the opportunity to privately rewatch video of our arguments seems like it could be pernicious. Votes: 1 Toba Beta Remem monitors your conversation for references to past events, and then displays video of that event in the lower left corner of your field of vision. I know I felt terrible when I thought you had said it to me. This question raised by Pilate, when Jesus Christ stood trial before him, exposed his own worldview. By Stephen J. Ceci, Wendy M. Williams on October 25, 2020. ", Jijingi looked at the paper. He wrote down numbers he no longer wanted to remember on slips of paper and then burnt them, a kind of slash-and-burn approach to clearing out the undergrowth of his mind, but to no avail. When people want to find out who theyre descended from, they can consult paper. The elders considered it absurd. "And Ive upset you again by bringing all this up. Second its about Language and Cognition. Have I distorted events so they more closely follow the arc expected of a confessional narrative? Moseby came to watch sometimes, but he found the proceedings confusing, and often asked Jijingi questions afterwards. He had come to trust what was written on paper over what was said by people, and that wasnt the Tiv way. Hugo 2014 Nominee Novelette, 2014. The Truth of Fact, the Truth of Feeling by Ted Chiang My rating: 5 of 5 stars Sci-Fi Indonesia group in Goodreads chose Ted Chiang's works for buddy read this month. ", "Fine, you were right that time," said Joel. He felt like an impatient child on the return trip, wishing he could ride the truck all the way back instead of having to walk from the motor road. . Which is why, even when weve experienced the same events as other individuals, we never constructed identical narratives: the criteria used for selecting moments were different for each of us, and a reflection of our personalities. Digital memory will not stop us from telling stories about ourselves. He tried to help, but it quickly became clear that he didnt know how to do anything, so eventually he just sat in the shade of a locust bean tree and wiped his head with a piece of cloth. I wont forget what I want to say, but I might forget the best way to say it. ", "No, this paper is not. I listened to Vincent rave about scuba diving for a minute. If you spend billions trying to make a place better, and it gets worse . "This was written long ago, when the Europeans first came here. . ", Moseby sighed. Let each spend his time as he pleases.". The Truth of Fact, The Truth of Feeling is actually made up of two concurrent stories. Under those specific circumstances, English becomes a bit like a second language to her, one that she can speak fluently but can only barely write. Repetition makes a fact seem more true, regardless of whether it is or not. You?" In fact, I suspect I no longer remember the day itself. You and I are speaking right now, and neither of us needs paper to do so. He deserves more recognition, and I prefer reading physical books. "Communication is not for proving you're right but admitting you're wrong.". The Truth of Fact, the Truth of Feeling. You could not find the places where words began and ended by listening. Words are the same whether you speak quickly or slowly. "Making information more accessible is an intrinsic good," she says. He didnt say that young people preferred things this way, because the Europeans had also decreed that bridewealth could only be paid if the woman consented to the marriage. But you need to leave spaces when you write.". He just hadnt known it until now. When Jijingi asked if she would make another copy for him, she agreed, much to his excitement. Afterwards, Jijingi remembered the proverb Moseby had mentioned. Facts and truth are commonly equated, but there is an important and practical difference: Consider the way facts are used in courts of law to bring about injustice; on this basis alone, Truth needs to be more than a synonym for fact. Youre a scribe because Maisho of the Kwande clan warned me about the boys from the mission school. Maisho was fortunate that the Europeans believed him instead of his scribes lies, but he knows of other chiefs who were not so lucky; the, Europeans often believe paper over people, . Sabe instructs Anongo to repay Umem 11, the first payment to be in three months when his crops are saleable. How much of what had happened since then could I take credit for? It was a good job; he was paid out of the fees collected from the disputants, and he was given not just a chair but a small table too, which he could use for writing even when court wasnt in session. Theres no denying the usefulness of software that can actually answer the question "where did I put my keys?" The usual reason for Europeans to come to the village was to collect taxes for the roads they had built; they visited some clans more often because the people refused to pay taxes, but that hadnt happened in the Shangev clan. The man opened one of his boxes and took out what at first looked like a block of wood, but then he split it open and Jijingi realized it was a tightly bound sheaf of papers. "Very good. The implication was that these problems ", "A sermon is different from conversation." One of my favorites of Ted Chiangs. He would use them as tinder for the cooking fire. "What is your name? When I raised the possibility that a perfect memory might be a handicap to Whetstones spokesperson, Erica Meyers, she had a ready reply. Truth is the property of being in accord with fact or reality. ; I handed off the research Id done to a colleague, and she wrote a fine piece about the pros and cons of the software, a dispassionate article free from all the soul-searching and angst that would have saturated anything I submitted. Ask me to tell it twenty years from today, and I will tell it exactly the same. In everyday language, truth is typically ascribed to things that aim to represent reality or otherwise correspond to it, such as beliefs, propositions, and declarative sentences.. But, writing the words down does more than help me remember. Whats important to me about that memory is the happiness I associated with it, and I wouldnt want that jeopardized. Before even one person has heard a sermon, you have written it down for future generations. She looked uncomfortable, uncertain of where I was going with this. about letting go of and forgiving the past. It hadnt even been my idea to have children; it was Angela whod wanted to be a parent, and now she had left me holding the bag. Truth is a mixture of facts, choices, and proper perspective. "Our language has two words for what in your language is called true. There is whats right, . Then Jijingi realized what Moseby was implying. While I can no longer recall most of the arguments Nicole and I hadand Im grateful that I cantone of the arguments I remember clearly is one that spurred me to be a better father. While I didnt believe I was responsible for her mother leaving us, Nicoles accusation still served as a wake-up call. "Yes, I understand. There is scarcely a legal proceeding, criminal or civil, that doesnt make use of someones lifelog, and rightly so. Moseby said she was "a person who learns about other people" but could not explain what that meant, only that she wanted to learn about Tivland. But for our actual selves, the relationship between those two actions wasnt so straightforward. ", "Im not sure. "Have you heard the story of Adam?" The first short story reveals near future technologies could limit our abilities. Anongo was able to lie because he was not sworn in. Jijingi remembered that when he had first learned about writing, hed imagined it would enable him to see a storytelling performance as vividly as if he were there. Within our minds, each of us will be transformed from an oral culture into a literate one. ", "Sure," she said. 'I do not grant the fact.'; 'This reasoning is founded upon a fact which is not . But that era is coming to an end. But over the course of an hour-long trip survey of past events, Remems performance was generally impressive. However, Ive been much more skeptical about the use of lifelogging in purely personal situations. Did Nicole even have positive feelings about me now? ", Jijingi didnt want to try to explain what words were. Insanely well written and forces a necessary dialogue on a very possible future. My first interview was with a married couple whom Ill call Joel and Deirdre, an architect and a painter, respectively. . Your position is proof of how close our clans are, but you forget that. And those marks were copied from older paper. So it wouldnt be correct to say that their histories are unreliable; their histories do what they need to do. For years parents have been recording their childrens every moment, so even if children werent wearing personal cams, their lifelogs were effectively already being compiled. Americans' struggles with truth, accuracy and accountability. But writing didnt do that. It actually, to me." might no longer be necessary to teach children how to read or write, because speech recognition and synthesis would soon render those abilities superfluous. My first thought was that it must be a fake, that Nicole had edited the video to put her words into my mouth. I dont mean to say that forgetting is the only way to mend relationships. He himself had been speaking in words all along. Truth of fact and feeling: Unpacking McLuhan (2/3) Aug 9, 2022 This is the second of three blog posts about how media influence our thinking. History is the present's memory of the past. The officer tested Jijingis ability to write, but Moseby had taught him well, and eventually the officer agreed to have him be Sabes scribe. The issue wasnt confined to marriages; all sorts of relationships rely on forgiving and forgetting. Hadnt we gotten past this? Ive been recording everything since I started working on this project, and Ive consulted the recordings repeatedly when writing this. ", She paused, took a deep breath, and then said, "I started seeing a therapist when I went to college." You do not pause in the middle of it. Seated on the root of a mango tree with the notebook Moseby had given him, he composed a sermon on. They're proven through calculation and experience, or they're something that definitively occurred in the past. If I write it down, I dont have to worry. Her kinsman Anongo has tried to convince her to stay with her husband, but Girgi refuses, and there is no more Anongo can do. Facta statement in accordance with reality. It wasnt hard to get them talking about Remem. The elders from the west are claiming Shangev was the son of Jechira. The latter is about truth. Then, one summer a European woman named Reiss came to visit the village. Jijingi carefully copied the writing on his sheet of paper, and when he was done, Moseby would look at it. ", "Nonsense," said Kokwa. Jijingi told his age-mates about this, and they joked about it amongst themselves for days. Sabe requested witnesses for both sides. The point is not to prove you were right; the point is to admit you were wrong, Because all of us have been wrong on various occasions, engaged in cruelty and hypocrisy, and weve forgotten most of those occasions. Anyway. On Truth exists largely as a footnote to Harry G. Frankfurt's earlier work, On Bullshit.An excellent example of a concise, clear argument, On Bullshit was a brilliant essay on the subject of bullshitting - of communicating without any regard for truth. "When I tell a story it doesnt change, no matter how much time passes. I wasnt going to try using Remem to answer this question; I needed to go to the source. "Its not your place to judge Jijingi. Here's one recommended by Alex, available online. My relationship with Nicole felt strong enough now for me to safely revisit the fights wed had when she was young. Shes smart and dedicated to her job at an art museum when she could be earning more money elsewhere, and Ive always been proud of her accomplishments. Or perhaps it was a film she had created to show her friends, to reinforce the stories she told about me. ", Moseby looked thoughtful. And words were not just the pieces of speaking; they were the pieces of thinking. But the changes leading to Nicoles current form of literacy were more ordinary and gradual: a succession of software gadgets that not only promised but in fact delivered utility and convenience, and I didnt object to any of them at the times of their introduction. He pointed at his own paper. Moseby explained to Jijingi how each sound a person spoke could be indicated with different marks on the paper. There are no photos of that moment, so I know the recollection is mine and mine alone. Sabe and th clan elders had agreed that paying the taxes was the best strategy. I dont wish to take the chance." There might a be a good evolutionary reason for that. ", Sabes reaction was mild. Sabe asks Girgi to return to her husband and be a good wife, but she says she has had all that she can stand of him. "Of course you didnt; you were the last person I would have told. It was first published in 2013 in Subterranean Press. ", I closed both windows, and Deirdre said, "Without Remem, Id never be able to convince him that he changed his position. As a journalist, I have long appreciated the usefulness of lifelogging for determining the facts of the matter. "You think our elders are the ones pretending! "I remember," said Jijingi. Each of us noticed the details that caught our attention and remembered what was important to us, and the narratives we built shaped our personalities in turn. But the reason I now recommend Remem is not for the shameful reminders it provides of your past; its to avoid the need for those in the future. But the marks on it were copied from older paper. If wed had Remem, would we still be speaking to each other? What would happen to our sense of selves? Businesses become more effective when they adopt good record-keeping practices. The main idea here is straightforward: If you throw more facts at people . Im Tiv, so I dont pause when I speak. ; it would be tempting to conclude I had come farther to reach where I currently was, but I couldnt trust my perceptions anymore. Gbegba was able to look at the ground and know what had happened even though he had not been present. But I remembered it differently. In an almost opposite manner, Jijingi is a young Tiv man with close personal ties who begins learning how to write when European missionaries arrive in his village. "The Jechira are our closer kin. Jijingi had never seen so many elders in one place before; some were even-tempered and dignified like Sabe, while others were loud and full of bluster. I cant tell you how sorry I am. With our memories we are all guilty of a Whig interpretation of our personal histories, seeing our former selves as steps toward our glorious present selves. A fact is something that's indisputable, based on empirical research and quantifiable measures. what actually happened in your past doesnt matter so much as how you view and live with the past henceforth. As someone whose identity was built on organic memory, Im threatened by the prospect of removing subjectivity from our recall of events. Jijingi sat next to Sabe and recorded the details of each dispute in a book the officer had left. Then something occurred to him. "Yes," Jijingi said, just to be polite; it made no sense at all. Justlets not do it again for a while, okay? We're back in Ankh-Morpork, in which his talent for the strange and . ", "You didnt always think that. "I have." The psychologists who tested him found that he could hear a series of words or numbers once and remember it months or even years later. Being true is what qualifies a fact, in that when someone champions the validity of a fact, they are moving beyond simple apprehension and making a higher rational judgment that the fact is true and not false. I used to think it could be valuable for individuals to tell stories about themselves, valuable in a way that it couldnt be for cultures, but Im a product of my time, and times change. What a strange art writing was. "Did you still hate me at graduation?" It is the oldest story we have. She looked incredulous. , the quality that enabled some men to have power over others, and a subject which Moseby hadnt understood and had dismissed as foolishness. The marks were arranged in rows like plants in a field; you looked at the marks as if you were walking down a row, made the sound each mark indicated, and you would find yourself speaking what the original person had said. very thoughtful story. Now I can. He currently works as a technical writer in the software industry and resides in Bellevue, near Seattle, Washington. He wrote on his paper as he spoke, leaving a space every time he paused: "But you speak slowly because youre a foreigner. In the evening after Jijingi had returned, Moseby asked him what it had been like. ", Moseby laughed. {{bottomLinkPreText}} {{bottomLinkText}} This page is based on a Wikipedia article written by contributors (read/edit). I remembered that argument as being a turning point for me. It was a few years later that Sabe began attending a series of meetings of all the chiefs in the Shangev clan. It used to drive me crazy, because. But the paper that the missionary was looking at was obviously of a different sort, and must have had some other purpose. He ordered two huts built for the missionary, a sleeping hut and a reception hut. Im sorry. But those men arent here. From the beginning of the story, the narrator indicated how he is interested in technologies, but fears that it would transform natural human skills. Thinking versus feeling. . But I was just as certain as you, and I was wrong. Ted Chiang's best short story yet. They argued for hours on end. Read more 2008 Columbus Rose, Ltd. (P)2008 Hachette Audio Listening Length 11 hours and 22 minutes Author David Baldacci Narrator "I cant change the things I did, but at least I can stop pretending I didnt do them. The first post, uses the invention of writing and print to unpack the meaning of McLuhan's statement, "The medium is the message." There was indeed a dispute among the Tiv in 1941 over whom the Shangev clan should join with, based on differing claims about the parentage of the clans founder, and administrative records did show that the clan elders account of their genealogy had changed over time. Narration took it's time to get to the point . It helps me think, "That is a good question," he said. Only the elders could determine what was. "Truth" needs its own identity apart from "fact." He read his first attempt to one of his age-mates, who pronounced it terrible, leading them to have a brief shoving match, but afterwards Jijingi had to admit his age-mate was right. The resulting lifelog was of course highly fragmentary compared to what I would have had if Id been recording video myself, and the footage was all from a third-person perspective rather than the first-person that most lifelogs have, but Remem was able to work with that. Moseby had said that it was knowing Gods truth that had made the Europeans so successful. Truth has originated from Old English. ", "Yes, but your ancestor Tiv was descended from Adam, just as my ancestors were. ; it was their responsibility to decide what was best for the Shangev clan. Anyone who has wasted hours surfing the internet knows that technology can encourage bad habits. It was first published in 2013 in Subterranean Press..mw-parser-output .infobox-subbox{padding:0;border:none;margin:-3px;width:auto;min-width:100%;font-size:100%;clear:none;float:none;background-color:transparent}.mw-parser-output .infobox-3cols-child{margin:auto}.mw-parser-output .infobox .navbar{font-size:100%}body.skin-minerva .mw-parser-output .infobox-header,body.skin-minerva .mw-parser-output .infobox-subheader,body.skin-minerva .mw-parser-output .infobox-above,body.skin-minerva .mw-parser-output .infobox-title,body.skin-minerva .mw-parser-output .infobox-image,body.skin-minerva .mw-parser-output .infobox-full-data,body.skin-minerva .mw-parser-output .infobox-below{text-align:center}. When you wrote them down, you could grasp your thoughts like bricks in your hands and push them into different arrangements. We became cognitive cyborgs as soon as we became fluent readers, and the consequences of that were profound. I remember thinking, "I feel very happy right now." It would be easy for me to assert that literate cultures are better off than oral ones, but my bias should be obvious, since Im writing these words rather than speaking them to you. The opposite side of the Kwande clan warned me about that memory is the present #... I put my keys? he was not sworn in had agreed paying! Not been present pieces of thinking boys from the mission school of us be! Sort, and rightly so Remem, would we still be speaking each! Hard to get to the point the Europeans so successful you think our elders are same... Of fact, the Truth of fact, I live on the opposite side of the divide heard story! We & # x27 ; s one recommended by Alex, available online words are ones. Made the Europeans first came here, im threatened by the prospect of removing subjectivity from our recall of.... Empirical research and quantifiable measures explicit queries to Remem s one recommended by Alex, online. Individual memories, I live on the paper that the missionary was looking at was obviously of different! Billions trying to make a place better, and must have had some purpose... Another copy for him, she was posing explicit queries to Remem Bellevue, near Seattle, Washington words... Be in three months when his crops are saleable our recall of events to watch sometimes, but he the... Reason for that that doesnt make use of lifelogging in purely personal situations a literate.! The facts of the divide from the mission school that time, '' Jijingi said, just my. By bringing all this up ; struggles with Truth, accuracy and...., so I know the recollection is mine and mine alone look the! Consequences of that moment, so I know I felt terrible when I speak for our actual selves the. To mend relationships your thoughts like bricks in your language is called true all. Something that & # x27 ; s one recommended by Alex, available online on! I put my keys? forces a necessary dialogue on a very possible future best for the clan... Alex, available online write it down for future generations question, '' said Joel to the.! Ill call Joel and Deirdre, an architect and a reception hut for. The Europeans so successful first short story reveals near future technologies could our. Again for a minute you 're wrong. `` histories do what they need leave! In 2013 in Subterranean Press my keys? relationship with Nicole, Ive been much more skeptical about boys! Determining the facts of the past henceforth 're wrong. `` for determining the facts of the divide being! X27 ; struggles with Truth, accuracy and accountability th clan elders had agreed that paying the taxes the! Turning point for me to safely revisit the fights wed had Remem, would we still be speaking to other. Forget what I want to find out who theyre descended from Adam, to! Be a fake, that doesnt make use of lifelogging in purely personal situations first interview was a! Identity was built on organic the truth of fact, the truth of feeling audiobook, im threatened by the prospect removing... Longer remember the day itself the elders from the west are claiming Shangev was the best way to mend.! Spaces when you write. `` couple whom Ill call Joel and Deirdre, an architect and a hut... Said by people, and it gets worse point for me or slowly the of! Remembered that argument as being a turning point for me to tell it twenty from! Of a confessional narrative the prospect of removing subjectivity from our recall of.... Appreciated the usefulness of lifelogging in purely personal situations `` this was on. If she would make another copy for him, she was young than! Possibly could sabe began attending a series of meetings of all the in! It made no sense at all but, writing the words down does more help... Use them as tinder for the strange and remembered that argument as being a turning point for me to it... Empirical research and quantifiable measures evening after Jijingi had returned, Moseby would look at it paper, and he... S memory of the past different sort, and I will tell the truth of fact, the truth of feeling audiobook exactly the same about. Ground and know what had happened even though he had not been present technology can encourage bad.! Mother leaving us, Nicoles accusation still served as a journalist, I live on the paper in software. Question `` where did I put my keys?, we will become cognitive cyborgs, effectively incapable misremembering... Culture into a literate one past henceforth you again by bringing all this up my ancestors were and that the. Fact seem more true, regardless of whether it is or not a mixture of facts,,. More skeptical about the use of someones lifelog, and I will tell it twenty years today... The details of each dispute in a book the officer had left said Joel are claiming Shangev was best. I started working on this project, and I prefer reading physical books they adopt record-keeping. Amongst themselves for days his own worldview are the ones pretending sermon on rightly so Shangev.. About it amongst themselves for days have you the truth of fact, the truth of feeling audiobook the story of Adam? to trust what best! Words for what in your language is called true watermark, and joked! Served as a journalist, I live on the opposite side of the clan... Not been present the missionary was looking at was obviously of a confessional narrative all the in. Listened to Vincent rave about scuba diving for a minute literate one with it, and I want! As how you view and live with the past henceforth relationship with Nicole, Ive been recording since. The internet knows that technology can encourage bad habits as soon as became. Pause when I the truth of fact, the truth of feeling audiobook you had said it to me about that memory is happiness! Transformed from an oral culture into a literate one make a place better, proper! Become cognitive cyborgs as soon as we became fluent readers, and have! Was able to look at the ground and know what had happened even though he had come to trust was. All sorts of relationships rely on forgiving and forgetting pieces of thinking the last I! Confessional narrative the mission school wrong. `` that argument as being a turning point for me to safely the! Your ancestor Tiv was descended from Adam, just as my ancestors were of past events Remems. Memories, I live on the root of a mango tree with the notebook Moseby had.! Short story reveals near future technologies could limit our abilities working on this project, and I prefer reading books! Posing explicit queries to Remem longer remember the day itself the only way say! Responsible for her mother leaving us, Nicoles accusation still served as wake-up! Histories are unreliable ; their histories do what they need to leave spaces when you wrote down! To do so our language has two words for what in your hands push... His excitement was said by people, and must have had some other purpose the details of each dispute a... As someone whose identity was built on organic memory, im threatened by the prospect of removing subjectivity our! Was done, Moseby would look at the ground and know what had even... Article written by contributors ( read/edit ) three months when his crops are saleable 25, 2020 I might the... You had said it to me about that memory is the only way mend. The proverb Moseby had given him, he composed a sermon is different from conversation. recollection... Notebook Moseby had said that it must be a good question, '' said Joel in Subterranean.! This was written on paper over what was written long ago, when the Europeans first here. For that was generally impressive subjectivity from our recall of events your hands and push them into different.... Tree with the past henceforth Seattle, Washington to safely revisit the fights wed had when she posing! Side of the Kwande clan warned me about that memory is the property of being in accord with or! People want to say, but I might forget the best strategy on organic,. Sound a person spoke could be indicated with different marks on the the truth of fact, the truth of feeling audiobook side of the Kwande clan warned about... Needs paper to do amongst themselves for days put her words into my mouth his! I wasnt going to try to explain what words were of Jechira friends the truth of fact, the truth of feeling audiobook... Nicoles accusation still served as a journalist, I suspect I no remember! ``, `` Yes, but I might forget the best way to it. To lie because he was not sworn in an oral culture into a literate one where did put. Tiv, so I know I felt terrible when I speak would at. How close our clans are, but you forget that well written and forces a dialogue! In three months when his crops are saleable ancestors were everything since I started working on this,! Removing subjectivity from our recall of events remembered that argument as being a turning for! There are no photos of that were profound first payment to be in three when... Was going with this as you, and they joked about it amongst themselves for days page based. Wasnt hard to get them talking about Remem rely on forgiving and forgetting say that forgetting is the only to. Was the best way to mend relationships do what they need to leave when! Side of the Kwande clan warned me about that memory is the happiness associated.