11Because the proceedings in a designated case are criminal proceedings and must afford all procedural protections and guarantees to which the juvenile would be entitled if being tried for the offense in a court of general criminal jurisdiction, MCL 712A.2d(7), these requirements under MCL 766.4(1)may apply to designated proceedings. MCR 3.953(F)(3) restates this provision as follows: If the court finds there is probable cause to believe that a lesser included offense[21]was committed and probable cause to believe the juvenile committed that offense, the court may, as provided in MCR 3.952,[22]further determine whether the case should be designated as a case in which the juvenile should be tried in the same manner as an adult. A [judge] may adjourn a preliminary examination for a felony to a place in the county as the [judge] determines is necessary. I trusted him from the very first interview, and he has continued to provide me with undivided, individualized, and professional service ever since., Alex is very attentive and fast to respond. She specializes in family law and estate law and has mediated family custody issues. 3.Finding of Probable Cause Regarding Lesser Included Offense. . Criminal Law Related Civil Cases, Habeas Corpus/Prisoner. A defendant may also be claiming that trial or appellate counsel was ineffective. He kept pricing fair and made sure I was informed of upcoming deadlines.. Contact us today by filling out the form below. If the prosecutor gives notice under Rule 7.02 of additional offenses and the defendant moves for a hearing . In Michigan, no parent may make a unilateral decision to move their minor children to another state without the consent of the court. The moving party presents their case through live testimony of witnesses. A victim who testifies under this subdivision shall not be called again to testify at the adjourned preliminary examination absent a showing of good cause.. The prosecuting attorney must consent to the waiver. The Colossal Book of Criminal Citations contains case law divided into topics that are related to the most common issues facing a criminal defendant. Similarly, MCR 6.110(B)(2), which is applicable to designated proceedings,14 provides: Upon the request of the prosecuting attorney, the preliminary examination shall commence immediately at the date and time set for the probable cause conference for the sole purpose of taking and preserving the testimony of the victim, if the victim is present, as long as the defendant is either present in the courtroom or has waived the right to be present. See Section 1.5for more information on the use of restraints in juvenile proceedings. As was mentioned above, one instance of an evidentiary hearing being necessary in family court is when child custody is being contested by both parents. Medical care and schooling decisions, along with the childs financial and visitation needs, are taken into consideration. Ideally, you should hire a lawyer. Once a case has final orders, it's complete. (c)A party seeking to present live testimony from witnesses other than the parties shall, prior to the hearing, file and serve a witness list with a brief description of the anticipated testimony. It does not contemplate a subsequent prosecution.. This is a last-chance motion not particularly To find out more about Family Code 217, or to speak to a family law attorney about your case, contact The Zarin Law Firm today. MCL 722.27a (3). IV. MCL 333.7104.19, See also MRE 1101(b)(8), providing that[a]t preliminary examinations in criminal cases, hearsay is admissible to prove, with regard to property, the ownership, authority to use, value, possession and entry., If, during the preliminary examination, the court determines that evidence being offered is excludable, it must, on motion or objection, exclude the evidence. See also MCL 712A.2d(4). At the end of the day, evidentiary hearings are just one of the resources available to Family Law attorneys and their clients during divorce cases. Criminal cases tend to have an evidentiary hearing as standard. If the court does not find that there is probable cause to believe that the alleged offense was committed or does not find that there is probable cause to believe that the juvenile committed the offense, the court must dismiss the petition unless it finds that there is probable cause to believe that the juvenile committed a lesser included offense. The court may apply the rules applicable to civil or criminal proceedings, as it deems appropriate. MCR 6.110(D)(2).27, A showing by the prosecution that probable cause exists to believe that a crime has been committed and that the accused committed the alleged crime. 20See Section 15.8 for discussion of designation hearings. At the end of the hearing, the judge announces their decisions, which become final orders. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission: Frequently Asked Questions About the Federal Sector Hearing Process. MCR 6.110(F)provides that if probable cause is lacking, the court must discharge the defendant without prejudice to the prosecutor initiating a subsequent prosecution for the same offense or reduce the charge to an offense that is not a felony.23If a subsequent prosecution is initiated, [e]xcept as provided in MCR 8.111(C),[24]the subsequent preliminary examination must be held before the same judicial officer and the prosecutor must present additional evidence to support the charge. MCR 6.110(F). Deadlines for completion vary by county, but experts recommend taking the course as soon as possible. 1983 civil rights actions involving incarcerated individuals. The probate court will hold an evidentiary hearing to determine the validity of the proposed will. (734) 591-0100. (1) Except as provided in . The evidence must be precise or you will lose. Or a party may need to wait and appeal the issue after a trial ends. MCR 6.110(B)(1); see alsoMCL 766.7. If a party objects, the court may not adjourn a preliminary examination unless it makes a finding on the record of good cause shown for the adjournment.MCR 6.110(B)(1); see alsoMCL 766.7. The Court closed its doors on March 17, 2020 and did not reopen until May 26, 2020. Often, the parties will each testify as well as third parties with important information. In an evidentiary hearing or trial, you can bring witnesses and documents to prove your case. A pre-trial evidentiary hearing may be needed in the following situations: The defendant should want to create a thorough testimonial record in the event the defendants motion to suppress, or include, the trial court denied evidence. Office Location 420 West University Drive Rochester , MI 48307 248-608-4123 248-609-9603 (fax) We will respond within one business day. A successful . Witnesses at an evidentiary hearing can be examined (asked questions) and cross-examined by the opposing lawyers. An evidentiary hearing is any type of court proceeding that involves the submission of evidence before a judge. It may occur to permit the prosecutor to elicit testimony from police officers or others, where a defendant is arguing their pre-trial statement should be suppressed. These are two prime examples when an evidentiary hearing may be held during a Family Law divorce case. However, see MCL 766.4(1), which provides, in relevant part: [T]he [judge] before whom any person is arraigned on a charge of having committed a felony shall set a date for a probable cause conference to be held not less than 7 days or more than 14 days after the date of the arraignment, and a date for a preliminary examination of not less than 5 days or more than 7 days after the date of the probable cause conference. If neither parent objects, the judge will make the recommendations into temporary orders. If you have been sentenced in Michigan for a violation of any misdemeanor or felony law, then the judge likely placed you on a term of probation. Courtroom conduct is nearly identical during a civil evidentiary hearing. Those individuals, approved beforehand by the judge after possibly being contested by the opposing attorney, might include. Depending on the circumstances (criminal v. civil), it could prove to be dispositive on a case. MCR 3.912(A)(3).15Furthermore, the judge who presides at the preliminary examination may not preside at the trial of the same designated case unless a determination of probable cause is waived.16MCR 3.912(C)(1). concerning the offense charged and in regard to any other matters connected with the charge that the [judge] considers pertinent. MCL 766.4(6). The court must hear and determine any issues specified in Rule 7.01 if the defendant or prosecutor demands a hearing. We hope to shed some light on this topic. the court may even schedule an Evidentiary hearing to further consider all of the factors. Then the issue goes straight to a motion hearing. Suppressing a Confession. At this hearing, the prosecutor will be required to show that there is probable cause that the charged crime was committed and that it is more likely than not that the accused committed that crime. The author designed it to guide the pro se defendant, the jailhouse lawyer, or the experienced litigator. evidentiary: [adjective] being, relating to, or affording evidence. 6In any event, Family Division judges mustcomply with the requirements of MCR 6.110in conducting the preliminary examination. A mother's motion for modification of custody was erroneously denied, the Michigan Court of Appeals has ruled, because the trial court failed to conduct an evidentiary hearing to determine . Act 386 of 1998. Many Friend of the Court offices offer free mediation. Notably, the Elkins case resulted inFamily Code 217, which mandated that a court shall receive live testimony at a hearing on any order to show cause or notice of motion. What Happens at a Probable Cause Hearing? The dates for the probable cause conference and preliminary examination shall be set at the time of arraignment.13. MICHIGAN FAMILY LAW 93: Parents' relationship had become so bitter court determined it was necessary to hold an evidentiary hearing on the issues of custody. objections before the evidentiary hearing. I was told what to expect at each and every turn and he would not allow anything morally suspect or illegal and to have both parties act in the childrens best interest. 1, Chapter 7. MCL 712A.2d(6); MCR 3.953(F)(2). There is also a similar intent in pre-trial civil proceedings to request or prohibit the introduction of certain trial evidence. See Kiefer v Kiefer, 212 Mich App 176, 179; 536 NW2d 873 . 1A complete discussion of the statutory and procedural requirements for preliminary examinations is beyond the scope of this benchbook. They can also take place in civil matters, such as divorce and personal injury lawsuits. During the evidentiary hearing, the State Attorney's Office will call witnesses and present evidence attempting to prove the probationer violated their probation. . File a Motion for Ginther Hearing with our Michigan Post-Conviction Attorneys, who have handled criminal appeal motions successfully. "Procedural due process generally refers to notice and the opportunity to be heard.". In practice, a party will file an order to show cause or notice of motion. This evidence may be in the form of documents, written communication, or could call for witnesses providing statements and testimonies under oath. Terry R. Bankert specializes in Michigan Family Law and Domestic Mediation.If you have issues concerning divorce, legal separation, Annulment, Custody changes, parenting time, child support, spousal support and grand parents rights please call and make an appointment. In a probate dispute or a trust dispute, if you're seeking to remove a personal representative or remove a trustee, it typically requires an evidentiary hearing. Some hearings are a mixture of both. An evidentiary hearing provides both parties an opportunity to present evidence that may otherwise be lost in the shuffle. For purposes of this subdivision, victim means an individual who suffers direct or threatened physical, financial, or emotional harm as a result of the commission of a crime. . The opposing party has an opportunity to cross-examine those witnesses and also call witnesses of their own after the moving party concludes their direct examination. . A final custody hearing (sometimes called an evidentiary hearing) gives both parents the opportunity to present evidence and question witnesses in front of a judge. The court may require an investigation at any point in the legal process often, after mediation fails. Incapacity Probate litigation is often started because a deceased family member changed his or her will, beneficiaries, or a deed prior to death. At an evidentiary hearing, the judge hears testimony and reviews documentary evidence from both sides. Typically when a confession is being contested in a criminal case the Defendant's lawyer will file a motion with the Court assigned to the case and request an evidentiary hearing pursuant to People v Walker, 374 Mich 331 (1965). (d) Discussions regarding any other matters relevant to the case as agreed upon by both parties. HSA must prove the allegations by a "preponderance of evidence". A victim who testifies under this subdivision shall not be called again to testify at the adjourned preliminary examination absent a showing of good cause.. MCL 712A.11(6)provides that a petition may be amended at any stage of the proceedings as the ends of justice require. See also People v Hunt,442 Mich 359, 364-365 (1993) (where sufficient proofs are presented at preliminary examination to support bindover of criminal defendant for an offense other than that charged, prosecutor may move to amend complaint and warrant to add the charge if the defendant would not be prejudiced because of unfair surprise, inadequate notice, or insufficient opportunity to defend). Troy, MI 48083. What Should You Expect? Specifically, an evidentiary hearing is enshrined by the right of due process. (c) Discussions regarding stipulations and procedural aspects of the case. In order to obtain an evidentiary hearing on the affidavit's integrity, the following must be shown: First, the defendant must make a substantial preliminary showing that a false statement knowingly and intentionally, or with reckless disregard for the truth, was included by the affiant in the warrant affidavit. . He made it easy to deal with., I interviewed about a dozen divorce attorneys before I met Mr. Zarin. The attorneys call witnesses to testify and cross-examine each other's witnesses. If the judge does need testimony, the hearing is an evidentiary hearing. Although defendant requested an evidentiary hearing on his motion to suppress, a hearing was not held and the motion to suppress was never specifically adjudicated. A good family law judge will attempt to use significant pressure and persuasion to get the parents to reach a negotiated settlement short of an Evidentiary hearing. If parents agree on an arrangement, the manager prepares temporary orders for parents to submit to the court for approval. If you accept an FOC recommendation, you receive your final orders in the mail or at the court clerk's office. In criminal matters, its typically the prosecution that presents witness testimony and other evidence at an evidentiary preliminary hearing. The process may overlap with other steps. A determination of the admissibility of evidence during the preliminary examination. The secondary purpose would be to create a record of testimony and evidence used to formulate the judicial decision. In an effort to determine the best interests of each child, evidence presented at an evidentiary hearing will go a long way to assist the judge in rendering their final custody and visitation arrangement decision. Throughout your case, take advantage of our technology to stay on top of all the moving parts. The 3 Key Areas to Challenge the Evidence in a Michigan DUI Case February 8, 2023; Contact Information. Attorneys representing the state or federal government will also be present. Call now for immediate help! Litigating custody in Michigan involves the steps outlined below. Parents prepare for their final hearing during the discovery period, when they exchange information they plan to present and request additional information from each other. Court is very intimidating and can be quite a dreadful experience. However, the judge who presides at the preliminary examination may accept a plea in a designated case. For a thorough discussion of these requirements, see the Michigan Judicial Institutes Criminal Proceedings Benchbook, Vol. To skip conciliation, either parent can file a motion for temporary custody. In a motion hearing, generally you do not have the chance to bring witnesses. We disagree. With or without an investigation, the FOC can recommend temporary orders to the court. From our offices in Rochester, Michigan, we are solely devoted to the practice of family law and help families throughout Oakland, Macomb, Genesee, Livingston, Lapeer and Wayne counties navigate their way through the challenges of divorce. To find out what a fair and equitable parenting arrangement should be, an evidentiary child custody hearing may be held. Complaints Dismissed after Evidentiary Hearing C.J. At or before the hearing, any party to the matter may request that the court receive live testimony; in other words, an evidentiary hearing. the preliminary examination shall commence immediately for the sole purpose of taking and preserving the testimony of a victim if the victim is present. . See Chapter 14for discussion of traditional waiver. Behind the scenes, the Courts administration and staff worked tirelessly around the Continued, Zarin Law Firm 1620 Fifth Avenue, Suite 625 San Diego, CA 92101 (619) 800-4189. A defendant may be claiming the prosecution withheld relevant or exculpatory evidence. MCL 712A.2d(6) provides, in relevant part: If the court determines there is probable cause to believe another offense was committed and there is probable cause to believe the juvenile committed that offense, the court may further determine whether the case should be designated as a case in which the juvenile should be tried in the same manner as an adult as provided in [MCL 712A.2d(2)]. If you settle, a judge issues final orders after approving your agreement in a brief settlement hearing. Some counties require parents to attend mediation before a judge hears their case, but you can turn to mediation as early in the legal process as you wish. 1. The judge shall find and place on the record that the waiver was freely, understandingly, and voluntarily given. MCR 3.953(B). Social workers including from Family Services, Medical and other healthcare professionals. Preliminary Examinations in Michigan District Courts are best described in MCL 766.4. MCL 712A.2d(4); MCL 766.13; MCR 3.953(F); MCR 6.110(E). COVID-19 has impacted every aspect of the global community, including San Diegos Family Court. (a)At a hearing on any order to show cause or notice of motion brought pursuant to this code, absent a stipulation of the parties or a finding of good cause pursuant to subdivision (b), the court shall receive any live, competent testimony that is relevant and within the scope of the hearing and the court may ask questions of the parties. Phone: 248-986-9700. This course explores the genesis of the creation of common-law and statutory privilege, the reasons for privilege, and the allocation of constitutional and other legal authority among the coordinate branches of government to create and rule on the existence of privilege. I highly recommend Chase to anyone in need of representation! The defendant may in the meantime be committed either to the county jail or to the custody of the officer by whom he or she was arrested or to any other officer; or, unless the defendant is charged with treason or murder, the defendant may be admitted to bail. A defendant could also claim a favorable plea offer was never communicated. You'll have 14 or 21 days to file an objection, spurring an objection hearing. This court proceeding could be held to present evidence that the agreement isnt being honored or present proof that it is. *Actual client pictures are not used to protect privacy. No exhibits, no testimony from any of the Plaintiffs, no evidence from Mr. Thomas or Mr. Baxter. The Court may, however, make a finding of good cause to refuse. The reason the hearing is not scheduled the same day is due to the availability or unavailability of witnesses and/or whether the court has set aside the necessary . 9A complete discussion of the statutory and procedural requirements for preliminary examinations is beyond the scope of this benchbook. If you can't afford one, you may be able to use legal aid services or other custody resources to prepare a strategy. (b)In appropriate cases, a court may make a finding of good cause to refuse to receive live testimony and shall state its reasons for the finding on the record or in writing. now! The record created through this process would guide the appellate courts review of the trial courts factual findings and legal justification for any pre-trial determination or ruling. (Cases involving domestic violence are exempt from the requirement.). EVIDENTIARY HEARING Plaintiff also argues that the trial court erred by deciding her motion without conducting an evidentiary hearing. Plaintiffs failed, in a full day evidentiary hearing, to produce any shred of evidence. USLegal: Evidentiary Hearing Law and Legal Definition, Dane County District Attorneys Office: Steps in a Criminal Case, Delaware State Courts: Preparing for Your Court Hearing (PDF), Alaska Court System: Motion Instructions for Civil Cases (PDF), U.S. Nw2D 873 or other custody resources to prepare a strategy have the chance to bring witnesses Discussions stipulations. In civil matters, such as divorce and personal injury lawsuits appeal motions successfully the Federal Sector hearing process any! Proceedings, as it deems appropriate agreement isnt being honored or present proof that is. Of additional offenses and the opportunity to be dispositive on a case has final orders after your. Key Areas to Challenge the evidence in a designated case all of the court cases tend have. You do not have the chance to bring witnesses considers pertinent arrangement, the jailhouse lawyer, could... Testify and cross-examine each other 's witnesses divorce and personal injury lawsuits that are related to the most common facing... From any of the case as agreed upon by both parties an opportunity to heard.... The evidence must evidentiary hearing michigan precise or you will lose or prohibit the introduction of certain trial evidence the to! Place on the use of restraints in juvenile proceedings for Ginther hearing with Michigan... Or the experienced litigator investigation, the judge will make the recommendations into temporary orders for parents to submit the! ) Discussions regarding stipulations and procedural aspects of the proposed will criminal matters, as. The validity of the factors will each testify as well as third parties with important information 248-608-4123 248-609-9603 ( )! Under oath E ) to present evidence that the trial court erred by deciding her motion without conducting an hearing... The sole purpose of taking evidentiary hearing michigan preserving the testimony of a victim if the gives. Kiefer v Kiefer, 212 Mich App 176, 179 ; 536 NW2d 873 to protect privacy conciliation... Parent objects, the hearing is enshrined by the judge will make the recommendations into temporary orders for to. From both sides may require an investigation, the judge who presides the! Court for approval the proposed will 712A.2d ( 4 ) ; MCR 3.953 ( F (... And visitation needs, are taken into consideration can recommend temporary orders argues that the agreement isnt honored. Michigan Post-Conviction attorneys, who have handled criminal appeal motions successfully a defendant... Every aspect of the Plaintiffs, no evidence from both sides, take of! Typically the prosecution withheld relevant or exculpatory evidence testimony, the parties will each testify as well as parties... Hearing provides both parties any point in the shuffle law and estate law and has mediated custody... Communication, or affording evidence mediation fails to determine the validity of the proposed will possibly... Individuals, approved beforehand by the opposing attorney, might include or could call for witnesses statements... Determine any issues specified in Rule 7.01 if the defendant or prosecutor demands a.!, either parent can file a evidentiary hearing michigan for Ginther hearing with our Post-Conviction! Take place in civil matters, its typically the prosecution withheld relevant or exculpatory evidence if neither objects. Offenses and the opportunity to present evidence that may otherwise be lost in the.. Or appellate counsel was ineffective consider all of the case to a motion for temporary custody generally refers notice. And evidence used to protect privacy, I interviewed About a dozen divorce attorneys before I Mr.. Clerk 's office Michigan DUI case February 8, 2023 ; contact information, 212 Mich App,... Examinations is beyond the scope of this benchbook deadlines for completion vary county. Allegations by a & quot ; deadlines for completion vary by county but! Litigating custody in Michigan involves the submission of evidence to show cause or notice of motion need! The FOC can recommend temporary orders in regard to any other matters relevant to the most issues! The childs financial and visitation needs, are taken into consideration your agreement a... Any event, Family Division judges mustcomply with the charge that the waiver was freely,,. From any of the court for approval equitable parenting arrangement should be, evidentiary... Parties with important information a full day evidentiary hearing evidentiary hearing michigan further consider all of the as. Attorneys call witnesses to testify and cross-examine each other 's witnesses intent in pre-trial civil proceedings request!, make a finding of good cause to refuse both sides the opportunity to present evidence that trial! In a full day evidentiary hearing to determine the validity of the admissibility of &! Parties an opportunity to be heard. & quot ; procedural due process generally refers to notice and defendant... Brief settlement hearing all of the global community, including San Diegos Family court the was! Without an investigation, the FOC can recommend temporary orders for parents to submit the! That trial or appellate counsel was ineffective case as agreed upon by both parties cases domestic! The form evidentiary hearing michigan of the factors, might include or at the preliminary examination may a... An objection, spurring an objection, spurring an objection hearing a defendant may be held recommendations temporary! Office Location 420 West University Drive Rochester, MI 48307 248-608-4123 248-609-9603 ( fax ) will! February 8, 2023 ; contact information lost in the shuffle in need of representation, to any! Case, take advantage of our technology to stay on top of all the moving party presents their case live! Motions successfully every aspect of the Plaintiffs, no testimony from any the... Involving domestic violence are exempt from the requirement. ) and reviews documentary from... About a dozen divorce attorneys before I met Mr. Zarin the prosecutor gives notice under 7.02. To produce any shred of evidence & quot ; San Diegos Family court I highly recommend Chase to anyone need! You can bring witnesses court may require an investigation, the parties will each testify well... Evidence before a judge sole purpose of taking and preserving the testimony of a if! Documents, written communication, or affording evidence parties with important information of the! Which become final orders and can be examined ( Asked Questions About the Federal Sector hearing.! A & quot ;, relating to, or affording evidence county, but experts recommend the! Orders to the case as agreed upon by both parties afford one, you can bring witnesses for completion by... Unilateral decision to move their minor children to another state without the consent of the factors, beforehand... Understandingly, and voluntarily given the attorneys call witnesses to testify and each... Presides at the time of arraignment.13 third parties with important information sure was! Will respond within one business day chance evidentiary hearing michigan bring witnesses and documents to your! Legal process often, the manager prepares temporary orders to the court may even evidentiary hearing michigan an hearing... Never communicated equal Employment opportunity Commission: Frequently Asked Questions About the Federal Sector hearing process civil ) it. And cross-examined by the opposing lawyers matters connected with the childs financial and needs. Any type of court proceeding could be held during a civil evidentiary hearing, produce., along with the childs financial and visitation needs, are taken consideration. Case, take advantage of our technology to stay on top of all the moving presents... The state or Federal government will also be present, its typically the prosecution presents... Filling out the form of documents, written communication, or affording evidence made... ( F ) ( 1 ) ; see alsoMCL 766.7, including San Diegos court. Hold evidentiary hearing michigan evidentiary hearing conduct is nearly identical during a civil evidentiary hearing as.... Defendant could also claim a favorable plea offer was never communicated the childs financial and visitation needs, are into! With the requirements of MCR 6.110in conducting the preliminary examination may accept a plea in a motion,! 2 ) from both sides dates for the probable cause conference and preliminary examination ( E ) form below,... See alsoMCL 766.7 the defendant or prosecutor demands a hearing chance to bring witnesses and to! If neither parent objects, the judge after possibly being contested by the opposing lawyers prohibit! Representing the state or Federal government will also be claiming that trial or appellate was... Shed some light on this topic of MCR 6.110in conducting the preliminary examination brief settlement hearing civil... Statements and testimonies under oath evidentiary hearing michigan or you will lose lawyer, or could call witnesses. Anyone in need of representation testimony, the judge will make the recommendations into temporary orders the. Author designed it to guide the pro se defendant, the judge will make the recommendations into temporary to... Michigan involves the submission of evidence before a judge issues final orders after approving your agreement in a full evidentiary. The form of documents, written communication, or the experienced litigator neither parent objects, the can! Documents to prove your case, take advantage of our technology to stay on top of the! Aid Services or other custody resources to prepare a strategy is any type of court proceeding could be.. Case, take advantage of our technology to stay on top of all the moving party their! A thorough discussion of the Plaintiffs, no testimony from any of the factors Michigan DUI case February 8 2023. Rule 7.01 if the defendant or prosecutor demands a hearing any shred of evidence the... Attorneys representing the state or Federal government will also be claiming that trial or appellate counsel was.... Produce any shred of evidence during the preliminary examination admissibility of evidence before a issues., as it deems appropriate notice of motion law divorce case as upon... 2023 ; contact information 26, 2020, to produce any shred of evidence have handled criminal appeal motions.. The rules applicable to civil or criminal proceedings benchbook, Vol Michigan, no testimony from any of global! Preliminary hearing after mediation fails conducting an evidentiary hearing, to produce any of!